[441]Plan in Enlart, I, p. 505, Fig. 244.[442]Violet-le-Duc (Vol. IV, pp. 75-77) calls attention to the architectural refinements in this church, mentioning the use of arches flattened on their inner face and curved on the outer between the apse and triforium. It is also interesting to note that here as in Saint Remi the vault of the triforium differs from that of the ambulatory proper. The arrangement at Saint Remi has been described, that at Chalons consists of a simple four-part vault of trapezoidal form with outer and inner sides curved.[443]Examples at Strassburg, Cath., Neubourg (Eure), ch. (irregular type of ch. with central pier and triangular apse. See plan in Enlart, I, p. 590, Fig. 317) and Tewkesbury Abbey (here even the triangular bays open into chapels). See also Cléry (Loiret) (fifteenth century) (plan in Baudot and Perrault-Dabot, III, pl. 60).[444]Plan in Caumont, p. 396.[445]Examples not mentioned include, Beeskow; Keisheim; Stargarde, Johanniskirche (slightly elaborated); Treptow (considerably elaborated); Worms, Liebfrauenkirche; Arles, Saint Trophime, etc.[446]Plan in Gaudet, III, p. 247, Fig. 1108.[447]Plan in Gaudet, III, p. 240, Fig. 1104.[448]These two churches not only show the vault with simple added ribs but the last named is most interesting as showing an ambulatory equal in height to the apse, a most unusual arrangement.[449]This church also presents certain changes in the arrangement of the ribs but these are unimportant.[450]See also Kuttenberg.[451]A similar plan on a smaller scale and with only two side chapels occurs at Ville-neuve-le-Comte (Seine-et-Marne) (plan in Enlart, I, p. 485, Fig. 232) and the same arrangement in churches with central plan appears at Trier in the Liebfrauenkirche while other examples include Lisseweghe; Toul, Saint Gengoulf; Xant; Oppenheim; Ludinghausen; Anclam; Lübeck, Saint Jakob; Lagny (Seine-et-Marne) (illustrated in Lenoir, Part II, p. 207) and Kaschau (Hungary) (illustrated in Lenoir, Part II, p. 208). See also Enlart, I, p. 485, note 2.[452]Baudot and Perrault-Dabot, V, pl. 79.[453]Such chapels were frequently omitted all through both the Romanesque and Gothic periods even in churches with an ambulatory and were not therefore established parts of the church plan. For examples of such chapels see Enlart, I, p. 228 note 2 and p. 485 note 3 and Lasteyrie, p. 297.[454]For discussion of prototypes see Lasteyrie, pp. 187, 188.[455]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 301 and Enlart, I, p. 231, note 4.[456]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 301 and Enlart, I, p. 486, note 1.[457]See Enlart, I, p. 231, note 2.[458]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart I, p. 233, note 1 and p. 486, note 3.[459]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart, I, p. 233, note 2.[460]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart, I, p. 233, note 3.[461]Orcival (Lasteyrie, p. 297, Fig. 458).[462]For examples see Enlart, I, p. 233, note 3.[463]Rather rare in the Romanesque period. For examples see Enlart, I, p. 232.[464]See page173et seq.[465]For examples of square chapels see Enlart, I, p. 231, note 2 and p. 487, note 7.[466]For example, the chapels with other chapels added to them toward the east at Norwich cath. and Mehun-sur-Yevre (Cher) see Enlart, I, p. 234, note 4.[467]See p. 112.
[441]Plan in Enlart, I, p. 505, Fig. 244.
[441]Plan in Enlart, I, p. 505, Fig. 244.
[442]Violet-le-Duc (Vol. IV, pp. 75-77) calls attention to the architectural refinements in this church, mentioning the use of arches flattened on their inner face and curved on the outer between the apse and triforium. It is also interesting to note that here as in Saint Remi the vault of the triforium differs from that of the ambulatory proper. The arrangement at Saint Remi has been described, that at Chalons consists of a simple four-part vault of trapezoidal form with outer and inner sides curved.
[442]Violet-le-Duc (Vol. IV, pp. 75-77) calls attention to the architectural refinements in this church, mentioning the use of arches flattened on their inner face and curved on the outer between the apse and triforium. It is also interesting to note that here as in Saint Remi the vault of the triforium differs from that of the ambulatory proper. The arrangement at Saint Remi has been described, that at Chalons consists of a simple four-part vault of trapezoidal form with outer and inner sides curved.
[443]Examples at Strassburg, Cath., Neubourg (Eure), ch. (irregular type of ch. with central pier and triangular apse. See plan in Enlart, I, p. 590, Fig. 317) and Tewkesbury Abbey (here even the triangular bays open into chapels). See also Cléry (Loiret) (fifteenth century) (plan in Baudot and Perrault-Dabot, III, pl. 60).
[443]Examples at Strassburg, Cath., Neubourg (Eure), ch. (irregular type of ch. with central pier and triangular apse. See plan in Enlart, I, p. 590, Fig. 317) and Tewkesbury Abbey (here even the triangular bays open into chapels). See also Cléry (Loiret) (fifteenth century) (plan in Baudot and Perrault-Dabot, III, pl. 60).
[444]Plan in Caumont, p. 396.
[444]Plan in Caumont, p. 396.
[445]Examples not mentioned include, Beeskow; Keisheim; Stargarde, Johanniskirche (slightly elaborated); Treptow (considerably elaborated); Worms, Liebfrauenkirche; Arles, Saint Trophime, etc.
[445]Examples not mentioned include, Beeskow; Keisheim; Stargarde, Johanniskirche (slightly elaborated); Treptow (considerably elaborated); Worms, Liebfrauenkirche; Arles, Saint Trophime, etc.
[446]Plan in Gaudet, III, p. 247, Fig. 1108.
[446]Plan in Gaudet, III, p. 247, Fig. 1108.
[447]Plan in Gaudet, III, p. 240, Fig. 1104.
[447]Plan in Gaudet, III, p. 240, Fig. 1104.
[448]These two churches not only show the vault with simple added ribs but the last named is most interesting as showing an ambulatory equal in height to the apse, a most unusual arrangement.
[448]These two churches not only show the vault with simple added ribs but the last named is most interesting as showing an ambulatory equal in height to the apse, a most unusual arrangement.
[449]This church also presents certain changes in the arrangement of the ribs but these are unimportant.
[449]This church also presents certain changes in the arrangement of the ribs but these are unimportant.
[450]See also Kuttenberg.
[450]See also Kuttenberg.
[451]A similar plan on a smaller scale and with only two side chapels occurs at Ville-neuve-le-Comte (Seine-et-Marne) (plan in Enlart, I, p. 485, Fig. 232) and the same arrangement in churches with central plan appears at Trier in the Liebfrauenkirche while other examples include Lisseweghe; Toul, Saint Gengoulf; Xant; Oppenheim; Ludinghausen; Anclam; Lübeck, Saint Jakob; Lagny (Seine-et-Marne) (illustrated in Lenoir, Part II, p. 207) and Kaschau (Hungary) (illustrated in Lenoir, Part II, p. 208). See also Enlart, I, p. 485, note 2.
[451]A similar plan on a smaller scale and with only two side chapels occurs at Ville-neuve-le-Comte (Seine-et-Marne) (plan in Enlart, I, p. 485, Fig. 232) and the same arrangement in churches with central plan appears at Trier in the Liebfrauenkirche while other examples include Lisseweghe; Toul, Saint Gengoulf; Xant; Oppenheim; Ludinghausen; Anclam; Lübeck, Saint Jakob; Lagny (Seine-et-Marne) (illustrated in Lenoir, Part II, p. 207) and Kaschau (Hungary) (illustrated in Lenoir, Part II, p. 208). See also Enlart, I, p. 485, note 2.
[452]Baudot and Perrault-Dabot, V, pl. 79.
[452]Baudot and Perrault-Dabot, V, pl. 79.
[453]Such chapels were frequently omitted all through both the Romanesque and Gothic periods even in churches with an ambulatory and were not therefore established parts of the church plan. For examples of such chapels see Enlart, I, p. 228 note 2 and p. 485 note 3 and Lasteyrie, p. 297.
[453]Such chapels were frequently omitted all through both the Romanesque and Gothic periods even in churches with an ambulatory and were not therefore established parts of the church plan. For examples of such chapels see Enlart, I, p. 228 note 2 and p. 485 note 3 and Lasteyrie, p. 297.
[454]For discussion of prototypes see Lasteyrie, pp. 187, 188.
[454]For discussion of prototypes see Lasteyrie, pp. 187, 188.
[455]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 301 and Enlart, I, p. 231, note 4.
[455]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 301 and Enlart, I, p. 231, note 4.
[456]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 301 and Enlart, I, p. 486, note 1.
[456]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 301 and Enlart, I, p. 486, note 1.
[457]See Enlart, I, p. 231, note 2.
[457]See Enlart, I, p. 231, note 2.
[458]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart I, p. 233, note 1 and p. 486, note 3.
[458]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart I, p. 233, note 1 and p. 486, note 3.
[459]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart, I, p. 233, note 2.
[459]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart, I, p. 233, note 2.
[460]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart, I, p. 233, note 3.
[460]For examples see Lasteyrie, p. 297, and Enlart, I, p. 233, note 3.
[461]Orcival (Lasteyrie, p. 297, Fig. 458).
[461]Orcival (Lasteyrie, p. 297, Fig. 458).
[462]For examples see Enlart, I, p. 233, note 3.
[462]For examples see Enlart, I, p. 233, note 3.
[463]Rather rare in the Romanesque period. For examples see Enlart, I, p. 232.
[463]Rather rare in the Romanesque period. For examples see Enlart, I, p. 232.
[464]See page173et seq.
[464]See page173et seq.
[465]For examples of square chapels see Enlart, I, p. 231, note 2 and p. 487, note 7.
[465]For examples of square chapels see Enlart, I, p. 231, note 2 and p. 487, note 7.
[466]For example, the chapels with other chapels added to them toward the east at Norwich cath. and Mehun-sur-Yevre (Cher) see Enlart, I, p. 234, note 4.
[466]For example, the chapels with other chapels added to them toward the east at Norwich cath. and Mehun-sur-Yevre (Cher) see Enlart, I, p. 234, note 4.
[467]See p. 112.
[467]See p. 112.