Arnold Calvert occupied rooms in Bloomsbury; pleasant old rooms in a house which had been fashioned in Georgian times. It stood in a quiet street undisturbed by the noise of traffic or the shrieking of children at play. Even organ-grinders rarely came that way, as the neighbourhood was not remunerative. Consequently the house was mostly occupied by people of delicate health who disliked noise. Mrs. Varney, the landlady, was a motherly old person with rather a hard eye. At one time she had been on the stage, and traces of that period appeared in her deliberate movements and slow voice. She always seemed as though she were reciting Shakespeare with appropriate gestures, although she had played but minor parts in the dramas of the bard.
Arnold was Mrs. Varney's pet lodger. As he was on the stage she frequently gave him the benefit of her advice, and Calvert always received her stale instruction with good humour and attention. This obedience made her love him, and he benefited by having his rooms better looked after and his food better cooked than any of the other lodgers. Calvert had two rooms on the second floor, a bedroom and a pleasant sitting-room, the window of which afforded a view round the corner of the square out of which the street led. It was an oak-panelled room with a painted ceiling, and furnished in very good taste. Arnold detested the frippery with which many young men of the present day cram their rooms, and his apartment was essentially masculine. The carpet and hangings were of dull red, the chairs and sofa were upholstered in leather, and on two sides of the room were dwarf book-cases containing a well-selected library. Calvert was fond of reading--a taste he had contracted at college, and kept well abreast of the literature of the day. In one corner of the room stood a small piano. Over the mantel-piece was a collection of boxing-gloves, foils, masks, and suchlike things. Portraits of Magdalen College--which had been Calvert'sAlma Mater--and of those men who had been his contemporaries, adorned the walls. Then there were many portraits of Calvert in cricketing costume, in boating dress, in cap and gown, and in some of his stage characters. Altogether a manly, pleasant room, quite the place for a studious man to dream and work in. And as Arnold lived a quiet life, he indulged in literary pursuits, as the loose papers on his desk and the presence of a typewriter demonstrated.
He was fair and handsome, with a lean clean-shaven face of the classic type. His hair was curly, and well brushed back from a high white forehead, and his eyes were blue and deep. Most people have shallow eyes like those of a bird, but there was a depth in those of Calvert which betokened a man who thought. A handsome intellectual face on the whole, and usually bright with good health, good humour, and contentment. At present, however, it was rather clouded.
The cause of this dismal expression was to be found in the presence of two men who were seated near the window. Arnold himself, in riding-dress, stood on the hearth-rug with his hands in his pockets. He had come back from a ride that morning to find two gentlemen waiting for him. "Professor Bocaros," said Mrs. Varney in the hall, when she admitted him; "he's a gentleman though shabby. But the other, called Jasher, is as vulgar as his vulgar name."
"This was rather hard on Mr. Jasher, who was not so vulgar as the landlady made out. He was as stout as Bocaros was lean--a fair, complacent, well-fed, elderly man of the Falstaff tribe. Mr. Jasher looked as though he knew a good dinner when he sat down to one, and was quite able to appreciate delicate cookery and good wines. His round fat face was red and freckled, with rather full lips, twinkling grey eyes, humorous in expression, and his hair was plentiful if rather grey. With his fat hands folded sleepily on his rotund stomach, Mr. Jasher looked anything but an inquiry-agent. Yet that was his profession, as announced by Professor Bocaros. Arnold had received the intimation calmly, though with some astonishment.
"Why do you bring this man to me?" he asked curtly.
"Do you know who I am?" asked Bocaros in his turn.
Arnold nodded. "I do. There was a certain relative of ours who sometimes spoke of you."
"Flora Brand?"
Arnold nodded again. "Mrs. Brand," said he; "she was Flora Calvert, the daughter of my uncle. Your aunt, professor, was, I understand, her mother. But you doubtless know of the relationship, since she told me that you had seen her."
"Twice," interposed Bocaros quickly, and then wiped his mouth. "I saw her five or six years ago, and then shortly before her murder."
Jasher looked directly at Calvert as the professor made this statement, hoping to discern some emotion. But Arnold's face, doubtless owing to his stage training, betrayed nothing of his feelings. It looked as cold as the face of a Greek god, which he rather resembled in his looks. "I am aware that Mrs. Brand was murdered," he said; "my lawyers, Messrs. Laing and Merry, told me so the other day."
"Did they tell you about the money?" asked Bocaros, his big black eyes fastened eagerly on the face of his cousin.
This time Calvert coloured a trifle, and shifted his rather direct gaze. "Yes," he answered; "though I do not know by what right you ask me such a question."
"I am your cousin----"
"Even that does not entitle you to take such a liberty."
"Bocaros looked annoyed. I am the last man to take a liberty with any one," said he coldly, while Jasher's twinkling eyes watched his face and the face of Calvert alternately; "but Flora, when I saw her a week before she was murdered, told me that she had made a will in my favour. When I went to see Merry I was informed that she had changed her mind and had constituted you her heir."
"Quite so," assented the young man. "Mr. Merry told me all this, and of your visit. I rather expected a visit from you, professor. You want me to help you with money----"
"I want you to offer a reward in order to learn who killed your--our cousin," burst out Bocaros swiftly.
Calvert bit his lip, and the blood rushed to his fair face. "You may be sure that I will leave no stone unturned to learn the truth," he said, and walked in a rather agitated manner up and down the room. At length he came to a halt opposite Jasher. "You are a private inquiry-agent," said he. "Mr. Merry informed me that the professor, under the impression that he had inherited the money, employed you to hunt for the assassin of poor Mrs. Brand."
"Yes--yes," cried Bocaros, shifting his chair in great excitement. "And I bring him to you that you may employ him. I am poor--yes, I am very poor, but I do not want money. Spend what you would give me in paying Jasher to discover the assassin."
"Is this why you bring Mr. Jasher to me?" asked Arnold.
"What else?" said Bocaros. "I only saw Flora twice, but I liked her--she was good to me. I want to know who killed her."
"All the world wants to know that, professor."
"Pardon me," said Jasher, in his unctuous voice. "I do not think the world in general cares very much, Mr. Calvert. The world has grown tired of its nine days' wonder, and now is occupying itself in other matters. I pointed this out to the professor, and proposed that you should remunerate me for what I have done, seeing that he cannot pay me, and let sleeping dogs lie."
"Arnold looked up sharply. What do you mean by that expression?" he asked quickly. "Have you discovered anything?"
"Jasher produced a small note-book. I have set down one or two things. At present I am collecting evidence. When I have sufficient I will know how to move. But"--he closed the book--"if you would like me to destroy these pages----"
"Why the devil should I, man?" demanded Calvert, frowning. "As the cousin and the legatee of Mrs. Brand, I am doubly concerned in learning the truth. I agree to what the professor suggests. You shall search out this matter, and find out who killed the poor woman. I will bear all the expense. And if you bring the guilty person to justice, I will pay you five hundred pounds."
"Consider it done," said Jasher, nodding. "I'll engage to get at the truth. Five hundred pounds is worth earning."
"Are you satisfied?" asked Calvert, turning to Bocaros.
The professor, strangely enough, seeing that his errand had not been in vain, looked rather disappointed. "Yes," he replied hesitatingly; "it is good of you. I am very pleased." He rose. "Now we will go."
"No," said Arnold, touching him on the breast, sit down. "As I pay the piper, I call the tune. Mr. Jasher has passed from your employment into mine. I should like to know"--he turned to Jasher--"what you have discovered so far."
"Nothing easier," said Jasher, again opening his little book. "I have learned details from the papers, from observation, from Professor Bocaros, and from Mr. Tracey."
"Tracey!" said Calvert, starting. "I remember. He was the American whose car was stolen."
"You know him better than that, Mr. Calvert," burst in the professor. "He is engaged to Miss Baldwin, the great friend of the young lady whom you are to marry."
Arnold turned on the Greek sharply. "How do you know that?"
"I live in a house near Mrs. Baldwin. She is my landlady. I know Tracey and Miss Baldwin. I have met Miss Mason, and----"
"And Miss Mason told you," interposed Arnold.
"No. Mr. Tracey, informed by Miss Baldwin, told me. And it struck me as strange," added Bocaros, in rather a venomous tone, "that you should be engaged to the girl in whose house Flora was murdered."
"It belongs to her brother-in-law," said Calvert coldly. "Do you mean to hint, professor, that I know anything about this crime?"
"No," interposed Jasher, making a sign to Bocaros to hold his tongue, "he doesn't mean anything of the sort. Merely a coincidence, Mr. Calvert, such as will occur in real life."
"Of course." Bocaros nodded and spoke with less significance. "I mean that it is merely a coincidence."
Calvert looked from one to the other suspiciously, but set a mask on his face so that they should not guess what was passing in his mind. "We may as well understand one another," he said coolly. "If you, professor, or you, Mr. Jasher, are under the impression that I have anything to do with this crime--and you may think so from the fact that being notoriously hard up and notoriously anxious to marry Miss Mason I wanted this money--you are quite mistaken. I am engaged at the Frivolity Theatre from seven till close on midnight every night. I can prove what the law calls analibi, and if you will apply to the stage manager of the theatre, you may convince yourself of the fact."
"My dear sir," said Jasher deprecatingly, since Calvert was now his employer, "no one suspects you."
"I thought from what Bocaros hinted----"
"No! no! I said it was merely a coincidence," said the professor quickly. "The very fact that you are willing to employ Jasher, and offer so large a reward, proclaims your innocence."
"I have no need to resort to such things," said Calvert angrily. "I only learned that the dead woman was my cousin from the fact of the White Room----"
"But how did that lead to your identification of Flora with the dead woman?" asked Bocaros shrewdly.
Arnold seemed confused. "I saw in the paper that the White Room had been remarked by a man called Webb, who had communicated with the police. It was then found by Inspector Derrick that Mrs. Brand had been missing. I fancied that she might be the unknown woman. I was informed that this was the truth by Merry, who has communicated with the police. I did not see the body or I would have been able to identify it. But Derrick found a portrait of my cousin, and says it is that of the dead woman."
This was rather a roundabout explanation, and Bocaros curled his lip. In spite of his denial he seemed to suspect Arnold. But that Jasher touched his arm he would have asked a question. As it was he allowed the agent to speak. "You knew that your cousin had such a room?" asked Jasher.
"Yes. Certainly I knew."
"Then you have sometimes visited her?"
"I have. My cousin and I were good friends. I did not see much of her certainly, but I have been in her house."
"Did you know that Mr. Fane had a similar white room?"
"Yes. He told me it was his own idea. I said that some one else had been beforehand. That I had a cousin who had such a room."
"Did you mention your cousin's name?"
"Not at the time. Flora said that the White Room was her own idea, and Fane insisted that the idea was original, emanating from his brain. I thought it was a coincidence."
"There appear to be a great many coincidences about this case in connection with you," murmured Bocaros, but of this remark Calvert for his own reasons took no notice.
"Seeing that your cousin was killed in the White Room in Ajax Villa, Mr. Calvert," pursued Jasher, "did it not strike you that it would be wise to draw the attention of the police to the other White Room?"
"Certainly not. Why should I have connected Flora with the dead woman? I never knew she was missing until the man Webb of Hampstead drew attention to her disappearance, and by that time the White Room at Hampstead had become known to the police. In fact, the room there, taken in connection with Mrs. Brand's disappearance, made Webb write to the police. I don't see how you can blame me."
"I do not," said the agent patiently. "I am only trying to get at the truth."
"I don't know it."
"You know Miss Mason, and she is the sister-in-law of Fane----"
"What of that? Do you mean to hint that she----"
"No! no!" said Jasher hastily; "but it was stated at the inquest that Fane alone had the latch-key, that it was never out of his possession, that the man who made it--invented that particular latch-key I may say--never made another. How then did Mrs. Brand enter the house, and how did she know that the family were at the seaside?"
"I cannot tell you. Why do you ask me?"
"I thought Miss Mason--seeing that you are engaged to her--might have spoken out."
Arnold's face grew red. "I forbid you to bring Miss Mason's name into the matter," he cried imperiously; "she has nothing to do with this affair. She was stopping with Mrs. Baldwin on that night, and never went near Ajax Villa when her sister was absent. Fane and his wife were at the seaside--so were the servants. How can you implicate any of these people?"
"I don't say that I can," retorted Jasher. "I am simply groping in the dark. But the fact remains that Mr. Fane alone had the latch-key. It must have been out of his possession so that some one could take an impression and have a duplicate made, or----"
"Well, or what?"
"I'll tell you," said Bocaros coming away from the window, "or Mr. Fane must have been the young man who spoke to the officer and who killed the woman--poor Flora."
"You forget," said Arnold coolly, "it was proved that the woman was alive when the young man in question was talking to the policeman."
"On the contrary," said the professor smoothly, "it was proved that the woman--poor Flora--was dead three hours when the woman was singing and the young man luring the policeman away."
"How dare you say that the man lured the policeman away!" cried Arnold furiously; "your ignorance of English law, professor, excuses your loose talk. But you are accusing every one without any basis of fact. What is your opinion, Jasher?"
"I haven't got one as yet," said Jasher, putting his book away and rising; "so far I can't see light. But I will go away and search, and then come back to tell you if I have discovered anything."
"In what direction will you search?" asked Calvert uneasily.
"I shall search in the direction of the latch-key. Fane alone had it, so I want to learn Fane's doings on that night."
"He was at the seaside."
"So he says," said Jasher significantly.
"And so Mrs. Fane says," said Bocaros quickly. "Better look for the young man with the pointed beard."
"The police have looked everywhere and he has not been found," said Arnold calmly, "and I don't think he will be found."
The professor was about to speak when Jasher pulled him to the door. When there he spoke. "By the way, Mr. Calvert, did you ever see Mr. Brand?" he asked.
"No. I never did."
"Did you ever see his portrait?"
"No"--but this time Calvert's denial was not so emphatic--"I didn't."
Jasher nodded. "That's all right," said he. "I'll come back in a few days and tell you about the latch-key."
When the two withdrew, Calvert sat down in an armchair and buried his face in his hands. His head was whirling, and his mind was much troubled. So buried was he in his reflections that he did not hear the door open. He was not conscious that any one was in the room till a hand was laid on his shoulders. With a start he sprang to his feet. He looked and saw Laura Mason.
The lovers looked at one another in terror. Calvert, surprised by Laura's sudden entrance, had no time to compose his features. She, seeing his face, and coming to him already filled with suspicions against which she strove vainly to fight, reflected the paleness and haggard looks which startled her. For the moment both masks had dropped, and these human beings, devoured by terror, stared at one another as though the fabled Gorgon had changed them into stone. Arnold was the first to recover himself. He smoothed his face to a smile, and held out his hands, which she took in a passive manner. "I did not expect to see you here, dearest," he said, leading her to a chair. "But how ill you look. Nothing is wrong, I hope."
Laura sat down still gazing at him, but did not reply. "How does my sister's maid come to be in this house?" she asked abruptly.
"Your sister's maid?" he repeated, staring.
"Yes; Emily Doon. I saw her in the hall as the landlady let me in. As soon as she caught sight of me she vanished down the stairs to the basement. And those two men----"
"One question at a time, dear," said Arnold calmly. He had now quite recovered his composure, and was prepared to deal with the situation. "And I shall answer the last first. The men who left me are a Mr. Jasher and Professor----"
"Bocaros," cried Laura, striking her gloved hands together. "I thought I knew his face. I saw him once at Mrs. Baldwin's. He lives in a cottage across the meadow, and sometimes comes to borrow her paper. What a horrid face--what a detestable man!"
Arnold looked rather surprised at her vehemence. "I certainly do not like the professor, and I met him to-day for the first time. It happens oddly enough that we are connected."
"Connected?" echoed Laura. "Wait; I have some sort of idea. The professor told Mr. Tracey that he was a cousin of this woman who was killed at Ajax Villa----"
"Her mother was the aunt of Bocaros," explained Calvert.
"And you are a cousin of the dead woman?"
"She was Flora Calvert before she married Brand, the daughter of my uncle. Bocaros and I are connected in a way by marriage. As to Mrs. Fane's maid being here--we shall soon learn the reason," and he touched the button of the electric bell.
Mrs. Varney, with her majestic air and false smile, answered so rapidly that it would seem she had been watching, if such a stately female would descend so low. She smiled ingratiatingly on Laura, who, without waiting for Arnold to speak, put the question. "I saw my sister's maid, Emily Doon, as I entered," she said; "what is she doing here?"
"What eyes you have, miss, I declare," said Mrs. Varney in her deep voice. "Yes, miss, it is Emily. She is my younger sister. I was a Miss Doon before I became Mrs. Varney. Your sister kindly gave Emily permission to spend a happy day with me, and this afternoon we are going to a matinée--Hamlet," said the landlady in her most serious voice, "the whole of it--lasting five hours."
Having thus stated her case, Mrs. Varney waited in the attitude of a startled fawn for a reply. Laura apologised. "I beg your pardon for asking," she said colouring; "it is, of course, none of my business, but I was naturally surprised at seeing Emily here."
"Ah," Mrs. Varney cast a look at Arnold, "we know all, miss. Emily has told me. Juliet's garden--and the Forest of Arden----"
"We are engaged, Mrs. Varney," said Arnold, enraged by the impertinence of the landlady.
With her false smile she turned to the door. "Certainly, sir, but as Miss Mason is in the Forest of Arden I would like her to know that Emily is likewise there. That was why she was in the hall. She has an eye to Professor Bocaros," burst out Mrs. Varney with pride; "he admiring her greatly, and living in the vicinity of Ajax Villa. Good-day, miss, and----" the landlady looked as though she would have liked to add, "Bless you!" but an imperious glance from Arnold sent her rapidly out of the room. Stately as Mrs. Varney was, she loved to be bullied as all women in their hearts do. Arnold's imperious manner only made her admire him the more. Had he been a bully in addition, she would doubtless have adored him.
"I don't like it, Arnold," said Laura, starting to her feet when the door closed. "Professor Bocaros, in spite of his looks and poverty, is a gentleman. Why should he take notice of Emily, who is merely a servant? And she is here--oh, what does it mean?"
Arnold, amazed by this outburst, looked at her in surprise. "My dear, what does it matter?" he said, pressing her to resume her seat. "I don't care if Bocaros marries a laundress. He has nothing to do with me."
"He is a dangerous man, and you are in his way."
"Am I? What do you mean?"
"Can't you understand, Arnold? He told Mr. Tracey that his cousin and yours, Mrs. Brand, intended to leave him the money. I learned from Mrs. Baldwin, who heard it from the professor himself, that you have got the ten thousand a year. The professor is poor--from what Mrs. Baldwin told me he is wretchedly poor. Do you think such a man will tamely submit to the loss of a fortune? No, Arnold, no. He is dangerous. Take care. If Emily Doon has an eye to marrying the professor, she is not in this house for nothing."
Calvert tried to soothe the excited girl. "My dear, you are unduly suspicious. Mrs. Varney has given us the reason for the maid's being here. Bocaros cannot harm me in any way----"
"Are you so sure?" asked Laura sharply.
"What do you mean?" he asked.
"I mean that you will not be open with me. I love you. Have I not proved how I love you. Julia is against our marriage: but in spite of what she says I have remained true to you. Yet you will not trust me?"
"With what? I am quite in the dark."
He may have been. Yet there was a deep colour in his cheeks, and he looked uneasy. Laura saw these symptoms of emotion, and placed her hands on his shoulders. "Arnold," she said earnestly, "if you have any love for me you will speak out. Look at this!" she hastily drew from her pocket the stage dagger. "This is yours?"
"It is," he admitted readily, and with a look of great surprise. "If you remember it was bought by me for the second act of this play. I showed it to you and----"
"You did. You showed it to me before the murder!"
Arnold looked at her in silence. "Perhaps you will permit me to explain," he said coldly, "as I really do not understand what you mean by such a speech. I lost that dagger----"
"You threw it into the dustbin after killing that poor woman!"
"Laura!" Calvert rose to his feet pale and trembling. From being a calm and resolute man he suddenly seemed to change into a coward. With white lips and a drooping figure, he stood in the middle of the room. "You will never say anything more cruel than that to me," he said in a low voice, and covered his face.
Laura looked with sudden joy overspreading her face. "You are innocent," she cried, running to throw her arms round his neck. "I knew it. I was certain. Dearest, I never believed--never. I said what I did say only to try you. But I know now that you did not kill this woman. I feel it in my heart. You forgive me--you forgive me--come, kiss me, Arnold--kiss me and make friends."
In a lifeless manner he kissed her, and then submitted to be taken to his former seat. "Now that we understand one another," said Laura, sitting down and keeping his hand imprisoned within her own, "we must have a long talk. You are innocent----"
"How can you be sure of that?"
"Because I am," she replied determinedly. "No, Arnold. Even if you swore that you were guilty I would not believe it. I tried you by making what you truthfully call a cruel speech, and your reply, although it may sound nothing to other people, brought conviction into my heart. But if I trust you, other people don't. This dagger!"
"Where was it found?" asked Calvert, examining it, but still pale.
"In the dustbin. The cook found it. She brought it to Julia, who pretended that it was one she had worn at a fancy ball. Then Julia hinted at your guilt, from the fact that you must have worn such a dagger in the second act of the play. I denied that this was so, and came to see you. Arnold, you must be plain with me. For some time, since the murder in fact, you must have seen how I have avoided you--how I have kept out of your way."
"Yes," he said with bitterness, "I saw that. When I called at the house on that day a week or so ago, you avoided me. You have hardly replied to my letters save in the coldest way. You suspect me----"
"No," answered Laura quickly; "I do not, though I have cause to."
Arnold looked at her keenly. "What do you mean?" he asked quietly.
"Surely you remember the appointment you made with me?"
"What appointment?" he said, still eyeing her, and the colour again ebbing from his face.
"For the night of the 24th July at half-past nine--on the very night that poor creature was killed."
"Laura!" his voice was firmer now, and his looks expressed amazement; "it was you who made the appointment. You sent me----"
"Wait, Arnold. One thing at a time. There is something terrible and mysterious about this. I suspect pitfalls and snares likely to bring us into danger. I say, and I can prove it, that you made the appointment. I have your letter in my pocket asking me to meet you at half-past nine on that night. I would have destroyed it so as to put away all evidence of your having been at Ajax Villa on that night, but I kept it, as I wished to show it to you, and to ask how you came to gain possession of Walter's latch-key!"
"You sent it to me!" he said, much astonished. "I have your letter also. The key was lost."
"You dropped it in the road when you spoke to the policeman?"
Arnold nodded. "But how did you guess that I was the man who left the house--the man for whom the police are searching?"
"Mulligan described your dress and said you had a pointed beard. You have such a suit and such a beard in the last act of the play. I knew then that you came later than I expected to keep the appointment, and in your hurry you had left the theatre without waiting to change your clothes or take off the false beard."
"In that case," said Arnold, very pale, "you must think me guilty of Flora's death, seeing that I left the house when----"
"No," interrupted Laura quickly; "you did not come, at half-past nine, for I was at the gate waiting for you. I rang the bell, since you said you would admit me in your letter. As you came finally in your stage clothes, you must have been unable to get away earlier from the theatre. Therefore, as Flora was murdered before nine o'clock you must be innocent. But I never thought you guilty," she added tenderly, wreathing her arms round his neck, and whatever any one said I would never believe you killed the woman. You are not the man to commit a brutal murder. "Yet Arnold," her arms dropped and she looked anxious, "the evidence is strong. This dagger is yours, you left the house, the police are looking for you and----"
"All that goes for nothing, seeing I was not at the house before nine o'clock."
"You were not?" she exclaimed joyfully.
"No! Listen, Laura, and I will tell you the whole truth and you will see why I kept silent. Like yourself--seeing that you deny writing the letter----"
"Show it to me. We must have a clear ground before we can go further. Here is the letter I received. Look at it while I see if Mrs. Varney is lurking outside. I don't trust that woman, and now that I know my sister's maid, who loves Professor Bocaros, is here, I trust her less than ever. O Arnold, how I wish I had come to see you before!"
"It would have been better. Why did you not?"
"I was afraid. Arnold, how could I come to you and declare that the man I loved was guilty? I did not believe it--no--but I knew that you had the key--that you had been in the house on that night!"
"I can explain that," said Calvert quickly; "see if all is safe and return to your seat."
While Laura peered outside the door, he opened a cash-box and took therefrom a letter. This he laid open on the desk beside the letter given to him by Laura. When she returned, having ascertained that the coast was clear, he pointed to this last. "I never wrote that," he said firmly; "it is a forgery."
"And the letter you received is one also," said Laura, staring at the document; "and oh, what a clumsy one! See--I do not separate my words like that. I often forget to dot my 'i's' and cross my 't's.' The signature is excellent--exactly like mine, but the rest of the letter is very bad--not at all a good imitation."
"But you will observe," said Arnold, pointing again, "that you end 'yours in haste.' I thought the hurried writing was thereby accounted for. Although I never suspected but that the letter was yours, I certainly thought that the calligraphy was different to your usual neat handwriting."
"I always write neatly," she replied, "and this letter is one I should have been ashamed to send out. But I use this colour and texture of paper," she sniffed it, "and the same kind of scent. I wonder how the person who forged this came to get my stationery. But, Arnold, your letter is written from the theatre--here is the printed name both on the envelope and inside sheet. How could I doubt but that the letter, was yours. It came to me by post at Mrs. Baldwin's."
"And yours containing the latch-key came on the afternoon of the 24th July. It was delivered by messenger to Mrs. Varney, who brought it to me."
"What do you mean by containing the latch-key?"
"Let us examine the letter first. Then you will see!"
The letter to Arnold at his lodgings, written on perfumed, lavender-tinted paper, contained a few hurried lines asking him to meet Laura at Ajax Villa on the night of the 24th July at half-past nine. "I may be a little late," the letter continued, "so I send you the latch-key, which I got from Walter who is at the seaside. You can let yourself in." The letter ended with an admonition not to fail to keep the appointment, and was signed with what appeared unmistakably to be Laura Mason's signature.
"I never wrote a line of it," said Laura, very pale; "and I never sent the latch-key. Walter was at the seaside certainly, but he would not have given me the key out of fear of Julia. I stopped with the Baldwins and never went to the villa while Julia was away."
"The letter to Laura at Mrs. Baldwin's, written on paper belonging to the Frivolity Theatre, likewise contained a few hurried lines saying that the writer would be with her as asked, at half-past nine on the night of the 24th of July, that he would obey instructions if he was early and admit her into the house if she rang the bell. It also stated that his understudy would play his part inThe Third Manso that the appointment could be kept.
"I never wrote a line of that," said Arnold when Laura had finished reading the letter. "When did you get it?"
"On the afternoon of the 24th. I was astonished, as I knew I had not written you a letter about the villa, and I wondered how you would be able to let me in."
"Now observe, Laura," said Calvert, sitting down, "both these letters are delivered to you and I so late that there is no chance of our meeting for an explanation save at Ajax Villa. It seems to me like a trap--whether for you or for me I cannot say--perhaps for us both."
"Did you really come to the villa?" asked Laura, knitting her brows.
"I did. You were right in your guess about my being the man who spoke to Mulligan. When I received your letter I asked the manager to let my understudy take the part. He made some objection, but finally he gave permission for the change. Then I came home, intending to keep the appointment at half-past nine, and wondering what you wished to say, seeing that we had met three days previously, and then you had given no hint of your possession of the latch-key."
"I wondered in exactly the same way," exclaimed the girl. "I said to Mrs. Baldwin on Saturday night--thenight you know--that I would go out for a stroll, the evening being hot. Gerty was at the theatre with Mr. Tracey. I then went to the villa at half-past nine or a little later. I did not see you, and but few people were about. I slipped into the garden so as not to be seen waiting in the road. I was afraid lest any of Julia's friends should see me. I then rang the bell somewhere near a quarter to ten, thinking you had arrived and were within. I rang and rang but no one appeared, so I fancied you had not been able to get away from the theatre, and returned to Mrs. Baldwin. I said I had been strolling in the Nightingales' Walk."
"Did you see a light in the room where the crime was committed?"
"No! Had I done so I should have waited. But the villa was quite in darkness," said the girl decisively. "You did not come?"
"I did later. There was a chapter of accidents. I came home rather tired and lay down to sleep after dinner. When I awoke it was nine o'clock. How I came to oversleep myself I can't say. I usually waken when I wish. Then a message came from the theatre just as I was getting ready to come--although I knew I would be late for the appointment. My understudy was taken ill, so I had to go back and finish the play. Afterwards, so eager was I to see if you were waiting, that I left the theatre without changing my clothes. I took a fast cab and reached Achilles Avenue about twenty or fifteen minutes to eleven."
"Did you drive up to the door?" asked Laura.
"No; I thought, for your sake, it was best to keep my visit quiet. I left the cab in Circe Street, and walked to the villa. No one was about. I went into the garden, but did not see you. I then walked into the house, letting myself in by the front door. I knew that you must have gone away, but I opened the door, just to see if you had left a note. Also I saw a light on the second story and fancied you must have got in and were perhaps waiting for me. These things are rather contradictory," added Arnold, passing his hand across his face, "but the mystery of your letter and the appointment rather worried me. However, I went in, and up to the White Room. There I saw a woman lying, dead face upwards on the mat before the piano. I saw that she was my cousin and was horrified. I turned the body over, and found the wound. She had been murdered. I was horrified. At first I intended to give the alarm. Then I thought that I might be accused of the crime----"
"But you had no motive," said Laura, "unless you knew that the money would come to you in the event of her death."
"I did not know that," said Arnold quickly; "no one was more astonished than I when I heard of the will. But at the time I was overcome by the horror of the deed. I had not my wits about me. I wondered how Flora came there. Then, my being her cousin and having the latch-key. O Laura, can you not guess that I lost my head! waited to see how I could escape. I went down the stairs, and then opened the door. Mulligan was leaning over the gate. I went and spoke to him, and escaped in the way the papers stated. I lost the latch-key and so I was connected with the matter. Thanks to my stage dress and make-up, no one thought I was the man mentioned in the papers. I did not come forward at the inquest. Now that the money has come to me, I dare not come forward. Here is the motive for the commission of the crime,"--Arnold walked up and down the room feverishly---"no one will believe me guiltless. Laura, don't ask me any more. The peril of my position overwhelms me."
"Darling." Laura rose to embrace him. "I believe in your innocence. We will find out who killed the woman. Do you suspect any one?"
"No," said Arnold after a pause, and with an effort; "how can I suspect any one? I know very little of my cousin. But now that I have the money, I intend to learn the truth. Laura, Professor Bocaros seems to suspect me. I can't say why he should. He cannot possibly know I was at the villa on that night. He brought Jasher to me, and to avert all suspicion, I engaged Jasher to hunt for the assassin."
"O Arnold, have you laid that bloodhound on your own track?"
"Yes; it seems foolish, but it is wise. Even if Jasher does learn that I was at the villa, he will say nothing if I pay him well. He is a venal creature, as I gathered this morning. He may find the real criminal, and take this horror out of my life. If he does not, he will never hurt me if I pay. It is the professor I fear."
"We must keep the professor quiet, Arnold. Let Mr. Jasher hunt. He may learn the truth, and that is better than this suspense. But what of the dagger I brought you?"
"It is mine. But after showing it to you I went to see my cousin. I left it there, I fancy, and it must have been Flora who took it to Ajax Villa--Heaven knows why! Laura, what is to be done?"
"Wait! wait!" she said, with her arms round him. "You are innocent, and your innocence will be proved. You employ Jasher. I shall ask Mr. Tracey to help me."
Mr. Jasher was a man who in his time had played many parts on the stage of the world. He loved money, and the ease and comfort which a judicious expenditure of money would procure. But he was not sufficiently successful in making an income. Several ventures had turned out badly before he opened his private inquiry-office, and hitherto that had not seemed likely to be a triumph. The work was hard and the pay not very good, and for some months Mr. Jasher had been contemplating the wisdom of giving up the business and starting as a theatrical manager. He was fond of the stage, and in the United States he had produced several dramas at a dead loss. But the English people being less clever than the Yankees, Jasher thought he would again venture on a theatrical agency.
It was about this time that Professor Bocaros called to see him. A chance of making a great deal of money out of the simple scholar presented itself to Jasher, and he took up the matter himself. It was so difficult that the detective--for so he was in fact--did not think it wise to trust the elucidation of the mystery to meaner hands. He resolved to attend to it personally, and charge accordingly. The discovery that the money had passed to Calvert was not pleasing to Jasher, as he had now to deal with a man more shrewd and less inclined to pay largely. However, supported by Bocaros, Jasher called at the Bloomsbury lodgings of the actor, and ended, as has been seen, in getting the business of hunting down the assassin of Flora Brand. It was not an easy mystery to unravel.
"But the first thing to be done," said Mr. Jasher to himself in the solitude of his office, "is to find out what sort of a cove Calvert is. If he's what I call a stinger, I'll have to go straight. If he ain't, I'll buckle to and do my best. But in any way I'll get all the money I can out of him."
In pursuance of this amiable resolve, Jasher sought out several theatrical folk whom he knew well. The report of Calvert was that he had a strong will, but was very good-natured. It was considered that he would never be an actor, and old-fashioned stagers believed that it was merely through his good looks and his fashionable clothes he obtained engagements. But Jasher knew the jealousy of those connected with the green-room, and determined to see Calvert act with his own eyes. According to the force and talent displayed by the young man, he might be able to estimate the depth of his character.
Having thus made up his mind, Jasher treated himself to a seat in the pit of the Frivolity Theatre. The audience was small as the play was not a great success. "It's a good thing he's got this fortune," was the agent's reflection, "as this piece won't run long; and being out of an engagement, he wouldn't have much chance of marrying that girl he's sweet on, according to old Bocaros."
The play was not a good one; the best scene being in the middle act, wherein a masked ball took place. Calvert was dressed as a Venetian, and looked remarkably handsome in black velvet and gold. During the scene he had to draw his dagger, and this drew Jasher's attention to the fact that he wore such a weapon. But he did not give the matter much thought. It was only when Arnold came on in the last act in a tweed suit with a reddish pointed beard that he started. It occurred to him that he had heard from a friend in the police of how the young man met by Mulligan had been thus attired. A description of the young man, save in a vague way, had not been put into the papers. And probably Jasher, but that his mind was full of the murder, would not have noticed the dress and general appearance. As it was, the remembrance of the dagger and the fact of the tweed suit and pointed beard made him reflect. Also the fact that Arnold was engaged to the sister-in-law of the man to whom the villa belonged made him lay unusual stress on the matter.
"Blest if I don't think he's got something to do with the matter, professor," he said to Bocaros that same evening.
The Greek, anxious to know how matters were proceeding, had made an appointment with Jasher at a Soho restaurant after the theatre, and was now at the supper-table looking more haggard and lean than ever with his blazing eyes and funereal looks. Disappointed at being deprived of Mrs. Brand's fortune, Bocaros--as Laura surmised rightly--was angry with Arnold for having obtained it. The remarks he had made in the young man's presence were mere fault-finding words, as he had no reason, on the face of it, to suspect him of being connected with the crime. Moreover, Arnold's ready acceptance of Jasher as an agent to search out the matter must have done away with all idea that he was guilty. No man would be such a fool as to put a bloodhound of the law on his own track, and when he had succeeded in gaining his end without danger. But when Jasher made the above remark Bocaros looked at him eagerly.
"That is my idea," he declared quickly. "I have no grounds to go upon. But Calvert is engaged to Miss Mason. In her brother-in-law's house Flora was killed, so he must know something."
"Oh, I don't see that," mused Jasher; "you go too fast, professor. Of course those facts, and the fact that he gets a large income, may seem suspicious, but being engaged at the theatre every night puts his guilt out of the question. But to learn all I can about Calvert, I have asked his understudy to come to supper." Jasher glanced at his watch. "He'll be here soon, and then we can talk."
"From your description," said Bocaros, who stuck to his point, "Calvert is the young man who spoke to Mulligan."
"I think that. He has the clothes and the beard described by the officer. But if he was the man, he would hardly be such a fool as to retain such a make-up."
"Yes, he would," persisted Bocaros; "safety often lies in danger. If Calvert had changed his make-up and a description had appeared in the papers, suspicion would have been excited."
"True; but no description appeared, or only a vague one."
"Calvert did not know that. He thought it best to keep to his make-up, trusting that people--who are generally stupid--would never connect his stage appearance with that of the man in real life. He is the man, I am sure, and he came out of the house."
"But it doesn't say he killed Mrs. Brand."
"He had ten thousand a year to gain by doing so."
"Quite right. But the woman was killed before nine, and during that hour Calvert was engaged at the theatre."
"That's true enough," said the professor gloomily, "all the same it seems queer. I believe he is guilty."
"Hush!" said Jasher, looking round uneasily; "don't talk so loud. You never know who may hear. Keep to generalities. Ah, here is Hart."
"The young man who came to the supper-table was a languid and fashionable youth, who, having run through his money, had gone on the stage to delight the public. As yet he had not made a success, and, judging from his looks, never would. Having got into trouble over some gambling debt, he had enlisted the services of Jasher. That astute gentleman had managed to settle the affair, and Hart was consequently willing to be friendly. He sat down with a bored air, and declared that he was almost dead. He acknowledged his introduction to Bocaros with a slight and supercilious nod.
"You work too hard," said Jasher, when Mr. Hart was engaged in eating.
"It's hard work hanging round the theatre waiting for a chance," said the other.
"You have got one," said the detective; "ain't you engaged at the Frivolity Theatre?"
"Only as Calvert's understudy," said the discontented youth. "I have to be at the theatre waiting for my chance should he fall ill. He's too clever to let me go on, and he can't act a bit. I could make a magnificent part of the one he spoils." And Hart began to explain the lines upon which he would--as he put it--create the part.
"Have you never had an opportunity of playing?" asked the professor, piling up little bits of bread in a listless manner.
"I had once," said Hart frankly, "but just my bad luck. I messed up the chance."
"Ah," said Jasher quickly, "how was that?"
"Well, don't you say anything," said Hart, glancing round, "as it would do me harm with the profession. Nobody will take much notice so long as it ain't talked about. It's only known in the theatre, and Calvert, who is a good-natured sort of chap, promised to hold his tongue."
"Oh," said Bocaros, meaningly, and looking up with eagerness, "he promised to hold his tongue, did he? About what?"
"My messing up my chance. You see Calvert didn't feel well one night, and I went on. I did act A1, and was scoring all round, when I got so excited that I fell ill. My heart ain't very strong," added the youth, "and that's why I can't take Turkish baths."
"Well, well," said Jasher, looking a very benevolent stout gentleman, and sipping his wine with relish, "what happened when you fell ill?"
"Why, they had to send for Calvert. Luckily he was at his lodgings."
"Also ill?" put in the professor.
"No. He said he was ill, but he wasn't. He came and took my place for the last act, and they said he never acted better in his life."
"About what time does the third act commence?"
"About ten."
"And Calvert came to the theatre at that time?"
"A few minutes before," said Hart, attacking some cheese.
"So he was disengaged on that evening up to that time. Ill at home?"
"He was away from the theatre, if that is what you mean," said the young man, "but he wasn't ill, so far as I know, in spite of what he said. It was a fake of some sort. I guess there was a girl in it."
"What do you mean?" asked Bocaros excitedly.
Hart started. "Why, nothing. Only some of our chaps were ragging him about getting away that evening to meet a girl."
"Did he deny that he was going to do so?"
"No. He laughed and coloured. A shy chap is Calvert."
Bocaros intervened. "Can you tell me what night this was?"
"What do you want to know for?" asked Hart suspiciously.
"It's merely curiosity," said Jasher smoothly; "you needn't trouble about the matter, if you don't like."
"I don't care two straws," said Hart, with a good-natured laugh, "but I can't understand what you fellows are driving at. Catch me forgetting the night I got my chance. It was the 24th of July."
"Jasher and Bocaros looked significantly at one another, but the interchange was lost on Hart, who was attending to his wine. The conversation then drifted into subjects connected with Mr. Hart's career, and he finally departed quite unaware that he had been made use of.
"What do you think now?" asked Bocaros triumphantly.
"Well, Calvert was absent on that night, and he resembles the young man who lured Mulligan away. Also he wears a dagger in the second act of the play which he might have used."
"He did use it," said the professor positively; "the wound was made by a stiletto, according to the medical evidence. It is a stiletto he wears. And he was absent between six and half-past nine, the very time the doctor said the woman was killed. Besides," went on Bocaros excitedly, "Calvert knows Fane very well. He might have thus obtained possession of the key."
"Fane swore it was never out of his possession.
"He may have done that to shield Calvert, seeing the man is going to marry Miss Mason."
"True enough," said Jasher, rising. "Well, Calvert himself has given me the funds to prosecute the search. It will be queer if I run him down. I guess he'll be willing to let sleeping dogs lie if I do run him to earth."
"No," said the professor determinedly; "if Calvert is guilty he must be punished."
"You leave matters in my hands," retorted Jasher, his good-natured face growing black. "I'm going to make money out of this."
Bocaros changed the subject, for no apparent reason. "How did you get money to prosecute your inquiries?"
"Calvert told his solicitors to give me what I wanted. I saw Merry, and obtained a cheque for fifty. That's enough to go on with."
"What do you intend to do now?"
"Go to his lodgings and see what his landlady knows."
Bocaros thought. "There's another thing you might do," said he. "I know that Emily Doon is the sister of Calvert's landlady. You might question her. She will be with her sister to-morrow, and, as you know, she is Mrs. Fane's maid."
Jasher looked keenly at the professor. "That's the girl you are sweet on," he said smiling.
"What if I am?" returned Bocaros sharply; "she is a nice, good girl, and handsome. She adores me," cried Bocaros, on whose head the unaccustomed champagne had taken effect, "and I will marry her when I am rich."
"Will you ever be rich?"
"If Calvert is the man who killed Flora Brand, yes," said Bocaros, and with a grim smile he departed. Jasher looked after him and shrugged his shoulders.
"I must keep you in order," said he to himself, "or you will spoil the whole thing."
But however little the detective may have trusted Bocaros, he made use of the information he had received. At three o'clock the next day he went to ask if Calvert was at home. But he did not make the inquiry until he saw Calvert drive away in a cab. Mrs. Varney appeared with her ingratiating smile, and assured him that the young man was out. "He has gone to Troy," said Mrs. Varney, "but of course we know what that means. A handsome young lady, Mr. Jasher."
"Hullo!" said the detective, starting; "and how do you come to know my name, ma'am?"
"Oh,"--Mrs. Varney tossed her head in a light-comedy way--"my sister knows the professor, and the professor knows you. The fact is----"
"Oh, that's all right. The professor (and a nice gentleman he is, though but a foreigner) told me of his weakness."
"Weakness, indeed!" This time Mrs. Varney frowned as a tragedy-queen. "Professor Bocaros ought to be proud of having a handsome young lady like my sister admiring him."
"Well," said Jasher, who wished to get an interview with Miss Doon, and guessed the right way to go about the matter, "he is a man who will be able to give her a good position."
"Do you know everything about him?" asked the landlady eagerly.
"Everything. I am his man of business," lied Mr. Jasher.
"Oh!" She looked longingly at the detective, not suspecting his real profession. "Won't you come inside for a few minutes. My sister is with me, and I am sure she would be pleased to meet Mr. Bocaros's man of business. When she marries him she will naturally be brought much into contact with you."
"I fear I am too busy, ma'am," said the man, playing his fish.
"Oh, but do come in," pleaded Mrs. Varney.
"Well, then, for five minutes," said Jasher, and this was how he came in a short time to be seated in a cosy parlour opposite to a tall, bold-looking young woman, with a hard mouth and big eyes almost as large and black as the professor's own. She resembled her sister in looks, and was scarcely less theatrical. After expressing her pleasure at seeing Jasher, and being determined--as he soon saw--not to let him go until she knew everything about Bocaros, she invited him to a cup of tea. Mrs. Varney went out to get the tea, and Jasher found himself being pumped by Miss Doon.
"I met the professor quite casually," she said, "having been insulted by a man one evening in the Nightingales' Walk. I cried for help, and the professor smote the ruffian to the earth. Then he asked me into his rustic home, and was quite the gentleman. We have been quite the best of friends for over a year," sighed Miss Doon sentimentally, "and lately he has given me to understand that he desires a nearer and dearer tie."
"Why don't you marry him, then?"
Miss Doon smiled and looked significantly at the detective. "I do not care about living in so damp a house as 'The Refuge,'" she said. "I will marry the professor when he can give me a better home. I suppose he is not well off?"
"At present he isn't," said the professor's man of business, "but some day he may come in for a few thousands a year."
"Oh!" Miss Doon gasped, "how delicious. I would certainly marry him then and leave my present place. Not that I have anything to complain of," she added graciously, "but I have always felt that it was my high lot to be a lady of rank."
"Quite so. And if the professor gets this money he can resume his rank, which is that of a Greek baron."
"Oh, good gracious!" Miss Doon gasped again; "then I would be the Baroness Bocaros."
"Certainly. But you had better stop in your place for a time till the professor gets his money. I suppose you get on well with Mrs. Fane?"
"We are like sisters," said the fair Emily; "she entrusts me with all her secrets."
"Has she secrets?" asked Jasher quickly.
Miss Doon coloured, tossed her head, and bit her lip. She saw that she had said too much. "I am true to my mistress, sir," said she loftily, "and what she asked me to do, I did, without betraying her."
Jasher was puzzled. He thought the girl was a fool to talk thus, and wondered what Mrs. Fane could have asked her to do. However, it was not a propitious moment to get the truth out of the maid as she was now more or less on her guard, so he deftly changed the conversation. "I suppose you find Ajax Villa unpleasant after the murder?" he suggested.
Miss Doon closed her eyes. "Don't speak of it. My nerves are shattered. It's awful. And to think no one ever knew who killed the poor soul."
"I suppose you don't?"
"Certainly not," replied Miss Doon violently, "I was at the seaside with the other servants. I know nothing."
"Are the other servants pleasant?" asked Jasher, baffled again.
Emily shrugged her ample shoulders. "Oh yes," she said; "Gander, the cook, is the most amusing." Here she began to laugh. "We had such a joke the other day," she added. "I intended to tell the professor."
"What was that?" asked the detective carelessly. Miss Doon recounted the episode of the dagger. "It was in the dustbin, and Gander thought the jewels were real. She gave notice, only to find that the dagger was a stage jewel that had been worn by Mrs. Fane at a fancy ball."
"You knew that, I suppose?" said Jasher, much interested.
"No. She has not been to a fancy ball since I was with her, and that is three years. But she said the dagger was hers, and Gander was in a great state."
Jasher asked for a description of the dagger, which she gave. Then Mrs. Varney returned with the tea, and the conversation became more general. But the detective left with a firm conviction that Calvert had left the dagger in the dust-hole after killing the woman.