Effects of a general Poll-Tax.
In the year 1779, the taxes inEnglandamounted, I shall say, to 10 millions; I shall suppose too, that this was the tenth part of the general produce of the land and industry: therefore the 10th part of the nominal value of thatgeneral producebelonged to the tax, or wasnecessitated by the tax; the 40 shillings, which, to facilitate my operations, I shall also suppose to be the averageprice of the quarter of wheat, must then have been considered as thenecessaryprice, or the pricenecessitatedby the tax, and 36s.as thenaturalprice, or the priceacquiredby the sole,naturalincrease of the national wealth. But in order that those 36s.might be called thenaturalprice, the taxes should have been divided in such a manner as to load each particular article with a 9th part of its value; that is to say, that each individual, possessed of a property denominated 9, should see it charged only with one ninth more, in consequence of a general poll-tax, which we shall suppose to have been assessedwith the utmost impartiality. In effect, it appears, that in this case the proprietor of a quarter of wheat, who, in consequence of the tax, would have raised the wheat from 36 to 40s.could not be said to have injured the hatter, who would sell him for 40 guineas the 40 hats which, previously to the poll-tax, he used to let him have for 36 guineas. It also appears, that the hatter could not be injured by giving 10 to the workman, instead of the 9 which he had hitherto paid; and that, in fine,if 27 millions had proved sufficient for circulation formerly, three millions more, once found, were fully adequate to the annual and perpetual payment of those 10 millions of taxes, without any one being a sufferer, but at the instant of the first payment.This system is deficient only in point of practicability; it is not established inEngland: 36 shillings therefore are not thenaturalprice of wheat; the wheat certainly owes above 4 shillings to the taxes, if its current price amounts to 40s.
Let it be observed, nevertheless, that if the system of a poll-tax could be reduced to practice, if it were not of all systems the most absurd, though the easiest for government, if it were not of all systems that in which it is most evidently impossible to avoid thousands of injuries to the subject, one might establish now inEnglanda new tax of 10 millions annually, and pay it for ever, without altering in the least the condition of anybody,provided one could find previously, and once for all, 2,600,000l. and that wheat should advance in price from 40s. to 43s. 4d.and every thing else in proportion. This appears to me so glaringly evident, that it extorts from me the affirmative tone. Now as soon as this should be effected,the burden of the tax would clearly be NULL.
But, it will be objected, the price of wheat is not thus arbitrarily advanced:—certainly not; for were this to be the case, it might also belowered at pleasure, and wouldevery other day, alternately rise from 1 to 80s.and fall from 80 to 1, since for this operation (become indispensable) it would suffice that there should be in all the provinces ofEnglandas many bodies-corporate (corporations) inagriculture, as there are inindustry. I am even inclined to think, that it would then be minutely examined,Whether it be in fact advantageous to agriculture, that the merchants export more goods than they import?(a due attention being paid to the five articles so often mentioned, which render necessary the importation of bullion); a question of the utmost importance, to which I do not see that any body has hitherto attended, and which might be so easily determined, if my principles are just.